---
title: "Religious Accommodation at Work During the Holidays: The Rules | The Staffing Guide"
description: "Religious accommodation at work during the holidays after Groff v. DeJoy: undue hardship, handling time-off requests, sincerity, decorations and parties."
---

# Religious Accommodation at Work During the Holidays: The Rules

[How Staffing Works](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/how-staffing-works/)

Since June 2023, refusing a religious time-off request because it would cost you “a little” is no longer a defence. In Groff v. DeJoy, a unanimous Supreme Court held that an employer denying a religious accommodation under Title VII must show the burden would result in substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of its particular business. That changes how you should handle December requests for Christmas, Hanukkah, other observances and regular Sabbath days during the busiest weeks of the year.

This guide covers what the standard now means in practice, a step-by-step way to handle a holiday time-off request, the options to try before saying no, how far you can question sincerity, and how to keep decorations and parties on the right side of the law. It applies to employers with 15 or more employees, the Title VII threshold; state laws often reach smaller employers.

## What “undue hardship” means after Groff

Before 2023, many courts read a 1977 case as saying any cost “more than de minimis” was an undue hardship. The [Groff opinion](https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/22-174_k536.pdf) rejected that reading. The points that matter for a December rota:

- **The test is substantial cost in context.** Courts look at the particular accommodation and its practical impact given the nature, size and operating cost of your business.
- **Co-worker grumbling is not enough.** Effects on colleagues count only to the extent they go on to affect the conduct of the business.
- **Hostility never counts.** A hardship that comes from colleagues’ animosity to a religion, or to the idea of accommodation, cannot be “undue”.
- **You must look at options.** Concluding that making others work overtime would be a hardship is not the end of the analysis; other options also need considering.

The EEOC’s [religious discrimination page](https://www.eeoc.gov/religious-discrimination) now uses the same “substantial in the overall context” language and lists flexible scheduling, voluntary shift swaps, job reassignments and changes to workplace policies as common accommodations.

## Handling a holiday time-off request, step by step

1. **Recognise the request.** An employee does not need to use legal words. “I can’t work Christmas Eve, it’s a religious obligation for me” is enough to start the process.
2. **Talk it through.** Ask what time is needed and whether there is flexibility, such as attending an evening service and working a morning shift.
3. **Look for a no-cost fix first.** Voluntary swaps, a different shift on the same day, or a floating holiday.
4. **Then consider low-cost options.** Paid or unpaid leave, making up the time later, or occasional premium pay for a volunteer replacement.
5. **Measure any real hardship.** If nothing works, write down the specific, substantial business cost, in numbers where possible: unfilled safety-critical posts, contractual service levels, overtime that would recur every week.
6. **Record the outcome.** Note the options considered, what was agreed or why it was refused, and keep the record with other leave decisions.

### Options to try, from cheapest to most involved

| Option | Works well for |
|---|---|
| Voluntary shift swap with a colleague | One-off holy days in a staffed rota |
| Change of shift on the same day | Services at a fixed time, such as an evening Mass |
| Floating holiday or PTO | Observances not on your holiday calendar |
| Make-up time later in the week | Weekly Sabbath conflicts |
| Unpaid leave | Multi-day observances when PTO is used up |

The EEOC’s [questions and answers on religious discrimination](https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/questions-and-answers-religious-discrimination-workplace), issued in 2008 and since overtaken by Groff on the hardship standard, still gives practical guidance on these options. Employers are expected to make a good-faith effort to allow voluntary substitutions and swaps, but requiring other employees to swap involuntarily is generally an undue hardship. Removing only part of the conflict is usually not enough.

## Fairness between holidays

Many businesses close or run reduced hours on Christmas Day, which effectively accommodates one tradition by default. That is lawful, but it means requests linked to other faiths deserve the same seriousness. A practical approach is a floating holiday that any employee can use for a religious or cultural observance of their choice, alongside your fixed holidays.

When you plan the December rota, build religious requests in at the start rather than after shifts are posted. Our guide to [scheduling employees fairly over the holidays](https://russellstaffinginc.com/schedule-employees-for-holidays/) compares rotation, bidding and seniority systems; whatever system you use should leave room for accommodation requests. And if you are working out what to pay people who do work on a holiday, see [whether employers have to pay holiday pay](https://russellstaffinginc.com/do-employers-have-to-pay-holiday-pay/).

## Can you question whether the belief is sincere?

Only in a limited way. The EEOC Q&amp;A says that if you have a bona fide doubt, you may make a limited inquiry into the facts. Inconsistent past conduct or suspicious timing can be considered, but none is decisive on its own. Do not assume a request is insincere because the employee’s practice differs from what you understand their religion to require, or because they were not observant last year.

Most December requests do not justify any inquiry at all. Asking a long-standing employee to prove they attend Midnight Mass will cost more in trust than any day off.

## Decorations, parties and greetings

The legal rule here is about pressure, not tinsel. The EEOC states that an employee cannot be forced to participate, or not participate, in a religious activity as a condition of employment. In practice:

### Generally fine

- A decorated tree or seasonal lights in a common area.
- Employees displaying their own religious items at their desks, as long as they do not demean other faiths.
- Saying “Merry Christmas” or “Happy Hanukkah” to colleagues who welcome it.

### Avoid

- Making a prayer, blessing or religious service part of a required event without excusing those who ask.
- Treating one group’s religious expression differently from another’s.
- Letting “seasonal banter” turn into repeated remarks about someone’s faith, which can become harassment.

Inclusive messages are an easy win. For card wording that suits a mixed team, this collection of [holiday season messages that work for any tradition](https://lovelysms.info/holiday-season-text-messages-for-family-and-friends/) has plenty of options that do not assume everyone celebrates the same thing.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Can we make an employee use PTO for a religious holiday?

Often yes, if PTO is a reasonable accommodation and the employee has it available. Where they have run out, consider unpaid leave, a swap or make-up time before refusing. The EEOC expects employees to cooperate with a reasonable alternative you offer, even if it is not their first choice.

### We are short-staffed every December. Is that an undue hardship?

Possibly, but only if you can show substantial increased costs in the context of your business after trying the options. “We are busy” is not enough after Groff. Document the specific gap, the cost of covering it, and the swaps or volunteers you sought. Many December conflicts can be solved by planning requests into the rota early.

### Does a seniority system override a religious request?

A bona fide seniority system, such as one in a union agreement, has special status under Title VII, and you generally do not have to break it to accommodate. You can still look for voluntary swaps within it. If your “seniority” is just informal habit, it does not carry the same weight.

### Do part-time and seasonal staff have the same rights?

Yes. Title VII protects employees regardless of whether they are full-time, part-time or seasonal, and applicants too. A seasonal worker hired for December can ask for a religious accommodation, and the same undue hardship analysis applies. Short tenure is not a reason to skip the conversation about options.

### Should we have a written religious accommodation policy?

It helps. A short policy explaining how to ask, who decides and what options exist makes requests easier for employees and decisions more consistent for managers. Pair it with a floating holiday option and a note in the December rota announcement inviting requests early.

Plan religious requests into the rota early, try swaps and shift changes first, and refuse only when you can point to a substantial, documented cost. That is what the law now expects, and it is also how good teams get through December.

### Related Articles

📄

[Is E-Verify Required for Your Business? Federal and State Rules](https://russellstaffinginc.com/is-e-verify-required/)

Is E-Verify required for your business? Federal co…

📄

[Holiday Party Liability for Employers: Alcohol, Injury, Conduct](https://russellstaffinginc.com/holiday-party-liability-employers/)

Holiday party liability for employers explained: a…

📄

[Remote I-9 Verification: Using the DHS Alternative Procedure](https://russellstaffinginc.com/remote-i-9-verification/)

Remote I-9 verification: who can use the DHS alter…

📄

[How to Complete Form I-9 Section 2 Without Common Errors](https://russellstaffinginc.com/complete-form-i-9-section-2/)

How to complete Form I-9 Section 2: the three-busi…

📄

[How to Schedule Employees for Holidays Without a Revolt](https://russellstaffinginc.com/schedule-employees-for-holidays/)

How to schedule employees for holidays fairly: rot…

📄

[Rehiring Seasonal Employees: When You Need a New Form I-9](https://russellstaffinginc.com/rehiring-seasonal-employees-form-i-9/)

Rehiring seasonal employees: when USCIS treats a r…

### Recently Published

- [Religious Accommodation at Work During the Holidays: The Rules](https://russellstaffinginc.com/religious-accommodation-holidays-work/)
- [Discriminatory Job Ad Language: Phrases That Invite a Charge](https://russellstaffinginc.com/discriminatory-job-ad-language/)
- [Employer Responsibilities for Form W-4: Musts and Must-Nots](https://russellstaffinginc.com/employer-responsibilities-form-w-4/)
- [Contingency vs Retained Search: Choosing a Recruiting Model](https://russellstaffinginc.com/contingency-vs-retained-search/)
- [Is E-Verify Required for Your Business? Federal and State Rules](https://russellstaffinginc.com/is-e-verify-required/)
- [Where to Post Jobs for Free: Options That Actually Get Applicants](https://russellstaffinginc.com/where-to-post-jobs-for-free/)
- [Minimum Wage Increases 2027: An Employer Checklist for January 1](https://russellstaffinginc.com/minimum-wage-increases-2027-employers/)
- [New Hire Reporting Requirements: What to Send and When](https://russellstaffinginc.com/new-hire-reporting-requirements/)
- [Recruiter Replacement Guarantee: What a Fair One Covers](https://russellstaffinginc.com/recruiter-replacement-guarantee/)
- [Holiday Party Liability for Employers: Alcohol, Injury, Conduct](https://russellstaffinginc.com/holiday-party-liability-employers/)
- [Remote I-9 Verification: Using the DHS Alternative Procedure](https://russellstaffinginc.com/remote-i-9-verification/)
- [Salary History Bans: What to Ask Candidates About Pay Instead](https://russellstaffinginc.com/salary-history-ban/)
- [New Hire Paperwork Checklist: Federal Forms and State Extras](https://russellstaffinginc.com/new-hire-paperwork-checklist/)
- [Predictive Scheduling Laws Before Black Friday: Employer Guide](https://russellstaffinginc.com/predictive-scheduling-laws-black-friday/)
- [Staff Augmentation vs Managed Services: Which Fits Your Project?](https://russellstaffinginc.com/staff-augmentation-vs-managed-services/)

### Topics

- [Accounting Careers](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/accounting-careers/) (2)
- [Applying &amp; Interviews](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/applying-and-interviews/) (17)
- [Career Changes](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/career-changes/) (8)
- [Certifications](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/certifications/) (2)
- [Finance Careers](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/finance-careers/) (1)
- [How Staffing Works](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/how-staffing-works/) (13)
- [Pay, Tax &amp; Contracts](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/pay-tax-and-contracts/) (30)
- [Role Comparisons](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/role-comparisons/) (4)
- [Uncategorized](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/uncategorized/) (10)
- [Working With an Agency](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/working-with-an-agency/) (32)

```json
{
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "Article",
    "headline": "Religious Accommodation at Work During the Holidays: The Rules",
    "description": "Religious accommodation at work during the holidays after Groff v. DeJoy: undue hardship, handling time-off requests, sincerity, decorations and parties.",
    "url": "https://russellstaffinginc.com/religious-accommodation-holidays-work/",
    "datePublished": "",
    "dateModified": "",
    "author": {
        "@type": "Organization",
        "name": "russellstaffinginc.com"
    },
    "publisher": {
        "@type": "Organization",
        "name": "russellstaffinginc.com",
        "url": "https://russellstaffinginc.com"
    },
    "mainEntityOfPage": {
        "@type": "WebPage",
        "@id": "https://russellstaffinginc.com/religious-accommodation-holidays-work/"
    }
}
{
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "BreadcrumbList",
    "itemListElement": [
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 1,
            "name": "Home",
            "item": "https://russellstaffinginc.com/"
        },
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 2,
            "name": "How Staffing Works",
            "item": "https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/how-staffing-works/"
        },
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 3,
            "name": "Religious Accommodation at Work During the Holidays: The Rules",
            "item": "https://russellstaffinginc.com/religious-accommodation-holidays-work/"
        }
    ]
}
```
