---
title: "Salary History Bans: What to Ask Candidates About Pay Instead | The Staffing Guide"
description: "Salary history bans in California, New York and Illinois: what employers cannot ask, what to ask candidates about pay instead, and volunteered figures."
---

# Salary History Bans: What to Ask Candidates About Pay Instead

[Applying &amp; Interviews](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/applying-and-interviews/)

**Myth:** you can still ask about current salary as long as the question is marked optional. **Fact:** in New York State the law allows an applicant to disclose pay history only “voluntarily, and without prompting”. A question on your application form is prompting, whether or not it has an asterisk.

Salary history bans stop employers in covered states and cities from asking candidates what they earn or earned, and in some places from using that information even when the candidate offers it. What you can do almost everywhere is ask what the candidate expects to be paid. This guide covers how three state laws work (California, New York and Illinois), what the federal equal pay rules add, the questions to use instead, and what to do when a candidate volunteers a number anyway.

## Why the bans exist, in one paragraph

The EEOC’s [compliance manual on compensation discrimination](https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/section-10-compensation-discrimination) puts it directly: prior salary cannot, by itself, justify a pay disparity, because prior salaries can reflect earlier sex-based pay discrimination. If you set every offer at “current pay plus 10%”, any gap a candidate carried from a previous employer travels with them into your payroll. The state bans go a step further and stop the question being asked at all.

## Three state laws compared

| Point | California | New York State | Illinois |
|---|---|---|---|
| Can you ask about pay history? | No, orally or in writing, personally or through an agent | No, as a condition of interview, offer, employment or promotion | No |
| Can you ask former employers? | Seeking it through an agent is barred | No | Not spelled out on the IDOL page; read 820 ILCS 112 |
| If the candidate volunteers it? | You may consider it | Candidate may disclose without prompting; you may confirm only in one situation (below) | You may not use it, even if volunteered |
| Can you ask about expectations? | Yes, expressly allowed | Not addressed in the statute notice; the safe alternative | Not addressed on the IDOL page |

Sources: the California Labor Commissioner’s [Equal Pay Act FAQ](https://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/California_Equal_Pay_Act.htm) (Labor Code section 432.3), the New York State Department of Labor notice LS 604 on Labor Law section 194-a (effective January 6, 2020), and the Illinois Department of Labor’s [Equal Pay Act page](https://labor.illinois.gov/laws-rules/conmed/equalpay.html). Many other states and cities have their own bans; if you hire anywhere else, read that jurisdiction’s rule.

### New York’s one exception

Under the New York statute, an employer may confirm wage or salary history only if, at the time an offer with compensation is made, the candidate responds by providing prior pay information to support a higher salary than the one offered. In other words, verification is allowed only after your offer and only when the candidate uses their history to negotiate up.

### Illinois is the strictest of the three

The Illinois Department of Labor lists using salary history “even if the applicant volunteers it” as prohibited, and says a person may complain if, after volunteering prior pay, the employer relied on it in an offer. If you hire in Illinois, the practical rule is simple: do not record volunteered history at all.

## What to ask instead

The replacement question is about the future, not the past. California’s guidance confirms that nothing in its statute stops an employer asking about salary expectations for the position. Scripts that work:

- “The range for this role is $58,000 to $66,000. Does that work for you?”
- “What are you looking for in base pay for this position?”
- “Is there anything about pay or benefits that would decide whether you accept an offer?”

The first script is the strongest, because it starts from your range, which you have to post anyway in several states. Our guide to [pay transparency laws](https://russellstaffinginc.com/pay-transparency-laws/) explains how to set that range in good faith.

### Questions to delete from your process

- “Current salary” or “desired salary based on current pay” fields on the application form.
- “What are you making now?” in phone screens.
- Requests for a recent pay stub or W-2 before an offer.
- Reference check questions about pay, bonus or raises.
- Recruiter forms that collect “current compensation” on your behalf.

That last one matters. California bars seeking the information through an agent, and New York’s definition of employer includes recruiters and employment agents. Tell any agency you use, in writing, not to ask.

## When a candidate volunteers their number

It will happen. A candidate says, “I’m on $70,000 now, so I’d need at least $75,000.” What you can do depends on the state:

1. **Do not follow up with more history questions** (“what about your bonus?”). That turns a volunteered statement into an inquiry.
2. **Steer back to the role:** “Thanks. Our range for this position is $58,000 to $66,000, set by the role’s requirements. Is that range workable?”
3. **Decide the offer from the job**, the candidate’s qualifications and your internal pay for comparable work, and write down those reasons.
4. **In Illinois**, do not record the figure or use it.
5. **In New York**, verify it only if the candidate cites it after your offer to argue for more.

Candidates are often coached to negotiate from their current pay; this candidate-side guide to [negotiating a job offer](https://alljobboard.com/how-to-negotiate-a-job-offer-salary-benefits-and-more/) shows what they are told, which helps you anticipate the conversation.

## Current employees and promotions

The New York statute also bars requiring wage history from a current employee as a condition of promotion, and bars asking a current or former employer for it. You can, of course, use pay information you already hold about your own employee. What you cannot do is ask what a rival offered them in an earlier job.

## A one-week clean-up plan

1. **Day 1:** pull every application form, phone screen script and reference template. Search them for “salary”, “compensation”, “pay”, “W-2” and “stub”.
2. **Day 2:** replace history questions with an expectations question tied to the posted range.
3. **Day 3:** send written instructions to every recruiter and agency.
4. **Day 4:** brief interviewers with the volunteered-number script above. Our list of [interview questions employers should avoid](https://russellstaffinginc.com/illegal-interview-questions-employers/) pairs well with this briefing.
5. **Day 5:** set a rule for documenting how each offer was decided.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Is there a federal salary history ban?

No federal statute bans the question for private employers. Federal equal pay rules still matter: the EEOC says prior salary cannot by itself justify a pay difference between men and women doing equal work. So even where asking is legal, basing an offer purely on past pay is a risk if it produces a gap you cannot explain by job-related factors.

### Can I ask about competing offers?

Asking whether the candidate has other offers is a different question from asking past pay, and the three statutes discussed here target pay history. Be careful, though: in Illinois and New York, if the conversation drifts into the candidate’s current salary, you are back in prohibited territory. Ask about timing and decision factors, not amounts.

### Can I verify salary in a background check?

Not before an offer in the states covered here. New York bars seeking pay history from a current or former employer, apart from its narrow post-offer exception. Ask your background check provider to remove compensation verification from the package for roles in states with a ban.

### What if the job is remote and I am in a state without a ban?

Coverage depends on the law where the job is based or the applicant works, and each state draws that line differently. Rather than map every remote applicant to a statute, the simpler policy is one rule: never ask about pay history, anywhere. It costs nothing, and it keeps a single script for every interviewer.

Ask about expectations, start from your posted range, and decide offers from the job. That approach is lawful in every state on the list and fairer everywhere else.

### Related Articles

📄

[Pay Transparency Laws: Posting Salary Ranges the Compliant Way](https://russellstaffinginc.com/pay-transparency-laws/)

Pay transparency laws in California, New York, Was…

📄

[Illegal Interview Questions: What Employers Should Not Ask (and What to Ask Instead)](https://russellstaffinginc.com/illegal-interview-questions-employers/)

Interview questions employers should not ask about…

📄

[Are Unpaid Working Interviews Legal? What Employers Need to Know About Trial Shifts](https://russellstaffinginc.com/are-unpaid-working-interviews-legal/)

Are unpaid working interviews legal? Why trial shi…

📄

[Accounting Interview Questions and How to Answer Them](https://russellstaffinginc.com/accounting-interview-questions-and-how-to-answer-them/)

Technical accounting interview questions test your…

📄

[How to Use a Staffing Agency When Returning to Work After a Gap](https://russellstaffinginc.com/how-to-use-a-staffing-agency-when-returning-to-work-after-a-gap/)

If you have been out of work for a while, returnin…

📄

[Writing a resume for agency work](https://russellstaffinginc.com/resume-for-staffing-agencies/)

When a staffing agency receives your résumé, the f…

### Recently Published

- [Holiday Party Liability for Employers: Alcohol, Injury, Conduct](https://russellstaffinginc.com/holiday-party-liability-employers/)
- [Remote I-9 Verification: Using the DHS Alternative Procedure](https://russellstaffinginc.com/remote-i-9-verification/)
- [Salary History Bans: What to Ask Candidates About Pay Instead](https://russellstaffinginc.com/salary-history-ban/)
- [New Hire Paperwork Checklist: Federal Forms and State Extras](https://russellstaffinginc.com/new-hire-paperwork-checklist/)
- [Predictive Scheduling Laws Before Black Friday: Employer Guide](https://russellstaffinginc.com/predictive-scheduling-laws-black-friday/)
- [Staff Augmentation vs Managed Services: Which Fits Your Project?](https://russellstaffinginc.com/staff-augmentation-vs-managed-services/)
- [How to Complete Form I-9 Section 2 Without Common Errors](https://russellstaffinginc.com/complete-form-i-9-section-2/)
- [Payday Falls on a Holiday: When to Run Payroll Instead](https://russellstaffinginc.com/payday-falls-on-a-holiday/)
- [Pay Transparency Laws: Posting Salary Ranges the Compliant Way](https://russellstaffinginc.com/pay-transparency-laws/)
- [How to Schedule Employees for Holidays Without a Revolt](https://russellstaffinginc.com/schedule-employees-for-holidays/)
- [How to Hire Your First Employee: The Legal Steps in Order](https://russellstaffinginc.com/how-to-hire-your-first-employee/)
- [The True Cost of Hiring an Employee: A Q1 Budgeting Guide for Small Businesses](https://russellstaffinginc.com/true-cost-of-hiring-an-employee/)
- [Illegal Interview Questions: What Employers Should Not Ask (and What to Ask Instead)](https://russellstaffinginc.com/illegal-interview-questions-employers/)
- [Are Unpaid Working Interviews Legal? What Employers Need to Know About Trial Shifts](https://russellstaffinginc.com/are-unpaid-working-interviews-legal/)
- [Rehiring Seasonal Employees: When You Need a New Form I-9](https://russellstaffinginc.com/rehiring-seasonal-employees-form-i-9/)

### Topics

- [Accounting Careers](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/accounting-careers/) (2)
- [Applying &amp; Interviews](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/applying-and-interviews/) (15)
- [Career Changes](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/career-changes/) (8)
- [Certifications](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/certifications/) (2)
- [Finance Careers](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/finance-careers/) (1)
- [How Staffing Works](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/how-staffing-works/) (11)
- [Pay, Tax &amp; Contracts](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/pay-tax-and-contracts/) (27)
- [Role Comparisons](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/role-comparisons/) (4)
- [Uncategorized](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/uncategorized/) (10)
- [Working With an Agency](https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/working-with-an-agency/) (30)

```json
{
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "Article",
    "headline": "Salary History Bans: What to Ask Candidates About Pay Instead",
    "description": "Salary history bans in California, New York and Illinois: what employers cannot ask, what to ask candidates about pay instead, and volunteered figures.",
    "url": "https://russellstaffinginc.com/salary-history-ban/",
    "datePublished": "",
    "dateModified": "",
    "author": {
        "@type": "Organization",
        "name": "russellstaffinginc.com"
    },
    "publisher": {
        "@type": "Organization",
        "name": "russellstaffinginc.com",
        "url": "https://russellstaffinginc.com"
    },
    "mainEntityOfPage": {
        "@type": "WebPage",
        "@id": "https://russellstaffinginc.com/salary-history-ban/"
    }
}
{
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "BreadcrumbList",
    "itemListElement": [
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 1,
            "name": "Home",
            "item": "https://russellstaffinginc.com/"
        },
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 2,
            "name": "Applying &amp; Interviews",
            "item": "https://russellstaffinginc.com/category/applying-and-interviews/"
        },
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 3,
            "name": "Salary History Bans: What to Ask Candidates About Pay Instead",
            "item": "https://russellstaffinginc.com/salary-history-ban/"
        }
    ]
}
```
