New Hire Paperwork Checklist: Federal Forms and State Extras

Every new employee in the US needs two federal forms: Form I-9 (employment eligibility) and Form W-4 (federal tax withholding). Almost everything else on a new hire packet is either required by your state, required by a program you have joined, or simply good practice. Mixing those categories is how small employers end up with a 30-page packet that still misses the one state notice that matters.

Use the checklist below in three layers: federal must-haves, state and program extras, and optional policy documents. After it you will find a retention table (who keeps what, and for how long) and a note on what goes in which file.

Layer 1: the federal must-haves

Item Completed by When
Form I-9, Section 1 Employee By the end of day one
Form I-9, Section 2 You or your authorized representative Within 3 business days of the first day
Form W-4 Employee Before the first payroll; effective with the first wage payment
Name and Social Security number for payroll Employee provides; you record Before the first payroll
State new hire report You (the employee signs nothing) Within your state’s deadline; the SBA cites 20 days as the general rule

Two points the IRS hiring employees page makes that are easy to miss:

  • If an employee does not return a completed W-4, you withhold as if they were single. You do not hold their pay until the form arrives.
  • An employee who claims exemption from withholding must give you a new W-4 by February 15 each year to keep that status.

Form I-9 never goes to the government; you keep it. For the employer half of the form, our step-by-step guide to completing Form I-9 Section 2 covers each field.

Layer 2: state forms and program extras

These depend on where the employee works and what you have signed up for. Check each one.

State withholding certificate

Many states with an income tax use their own withholding form instead of, or alongside, the federal W-4. Download it from your state revenue department, not a third-party site, so you have the current year’s version.

Written pay notice at hire

Some states require a written statement of pay terms when someone is hired. The Department of Labor’s state payday table, for example, notes that South Carolina requires written notice of pay terms at hiring for employers with 5 or more employees. Other states have similar rules with their own content requirements, so check your state labor department.

State and local notices you hand over

Separate from the posters on the wall, some states and cities require you to give new hires specific notices, often about paid sick leave, workers’ compensation or wage rights. These change more often than the federal forms; recheck them every January.

E-Verify, if you participate

If you are enrolled in E-Verify, or a contract or state law requires you to be, the E-Verify case follows the completed I-9. USCIS also notes that E-Verify employers must accept only List B documents that carry a photograph, and must keep copies of certain List A documents if the employee presents them.

Benefits enrollment

If you offer a health plan or retirement plan, the plan’s enrollment forms, beneficiary designations and required plan notices belong here. Your plan administrator or insurer will tell you which notices are mandatory and their deadlines.

Layer 3: optional, but worth having

  • Signed offer letter confirming title, pay, schedule, start date and whether the job is exempt or non-exempt.
  • Handbook acknowledgement, a one-page receipt that the employee received the policies.
  • Direct deposit authorization with the bank details, collected securely, not by email.
  • Emergency contact form.
  • Confidentiality or IP agreement where the role touches customer data or creates work product.
  • Equipment receipt for laptops, keys, phones or uniforms.
  • Background check consent and disclosure, if you run checks; there are specific federal rules for the form, covered in our guide to background check requirements for new hires.

Keep each of these short and plain. A form nobody reads gives you little protection.

Retention: who keeps what, and for how long

Record Minimum period Source of the rule
Form I-9 3 years after hire or 1 year after employment ends, whichever is later USCIS
Employment tax records, including W-4 At least 4 years IRS, as cited by the SBA
Payroll records At least 3 years DOL Fact Sheet 21
Time cards and wage-rate tables 2 years DOL Fact Sheet 21

These are federal floors. Many states require longer for some records; California, for example, requires job title and wage rate history for each employee for the length of employment plus three years. When periods conflict, keep the longest.

The Department of Labor’s Fact Sheet 21 on FLSA recordkeeping lists the payroll items you must hold for each non-exempt employee, from the workweek start time to total wages each pay period.

Three files, not one

Sort the paperwork into separate files from day one:

  1. I-9 file. The I-9 and any document copies you made. Keep these together and away from the personnel file, so you can hand an inspector the I-9s without exposing anything else.
  2. Medical file. Anything with health information, such as a doctor’s note or a medical exam result. The EEOC’s guidance on medical inquiries says medical information must be kept confidential, on separate forms and in separate medical files.
  3. Personnel file. Offer letter, acknowledgements, reviews, pay changes.

Employee or contractor? The packet is different

None of the above applies to a genuine independent contractor, who gets a different set: typically a Form W-9 and, at year end, an information return. If you are not sure which you have, settle that first. For contractors, this paperwork to collect before paying a freelancer covers their side, and our guide to filing Form 1099-NEC for 2026 payments covers the year-end return.

A first-day sequence that works

  1. Before day one: send the offer letter, handbook and optional forms electronically, so the first morning is not a paperwork marathon.
  2. Morning of day one: employee completes I-9 Section 1 and the W-4 and state form.
  3. Within three business days: you examine documents and finish I-9 Section 2.
  4. Same week: file the state new hire report and enroll the employee in payroll.
  5. First payday: confirm withholding matches the W-4 and the pay stub shows what your state requires.

Once the paperwork is done, the more important work begins; our guide to onboarding a new employee covers the first weeks.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can new hire paperwork be completed electronically?

Yes for most items, including the W-4 and policy acknowledgements, provided your system captures a valid signature and keeps a retrievable copy. Electronic Form I-9 systems are allowed too, but they must meet the government’s standards for electronic signatures and storage, so check that your software vendor follows the USCIS rules before going paperless.

Do I need a new W-4 every year?

No. A W-4 stays in effect until the employee gives you a new one. The exception is an employee claiming exemption from withholding, who must submit a new W-4 by February 15 each year. You may remind all staff each January that they can update it, which is a sensible habit after a marriage, a new child or a second job.

What if a new hire refuses to give me their Social Security number?

You need it to report wages on Form W-2, and the IRS says an ITIN cannot be used in place of an SSN for employment. If the employee has applied for a number but not received it, note that and update the record when it arrives. A refusal to provide it at all is a problem you should raise with a payroll professional before the first payday.

Should rehired employees fill out everything again?

Mostly yes for tax and policy forms, because details change. The I-9 is different: depending on how long they were gone, you may update the original using Supplement B rather than starting fresh. Also check whether your state treats a returning employee as a new hire for reporting purposes, because the rules differ.

Two federal forms, your state’s extras, three separate files. Build the packet that way once and every future hire takes minutes, not an afternoon.