Here is the mistake most employers make with Form I-9: they hand the new hire a list and say “bring your passport”, or “we need your driver’s license and Social Security card”. It feels efficient. It is also one of the things USCIS says you cannot do, because the employee, not the employer, chooses which acceptable documents to present.
Section 2 is the employer’s half of the form. You (or someone you authorize) examine the documents, record them, and sign, within three business days of the employee’s first day of work for pay. This guide goes through it field by field, with the timing rule, the List A versus List B and C choice, receipts, and the errors that show up most often in audits.
The deadline: three business days, with two exceptions
USCIS’s Section 2 guidance sets the clock: complete and sign Section 2 within 3 business days of the date of hire. Its own example is that if the employee starts work for pay on Monday, Section 2 is due by Thursday.
The exceptions:
- Jobs lasting less than 3 days: Section 2 must be done no later than the first day of work for pay.
- Section 1 comes first: the employee completes Section 1 no later than the first day of employment. You cannot finish Section 2 against a blank Section 1.
You may complete the whole form after the offer is accepted but before day one. In that case, you enter the expected start date and correct it later if it changes.
Lists A, B and C: what the employee may show you
The employee chooses one of two routes:
| Route | What it proves | Examples of document types |
|---|---|---|
| One List A document | Identity and work authorization together | U.S. passport, permanent resident card, employment authorization document |
| One List B plus one List C document | B proves identity; C proves work authorization | B: driver’s license or state ID. C: unrestricted Social Security card or certain birth certificates |
Rules that follow from this:
- If the employee presents an acceptable List A document, do not ask for List B or C. If they present an acceptable B and C, do not ask for List A.
- Documents must be original and unexpired. The one copy USCIS accepts is a certified copy of a birth certificate.
- A Social Security card marked with a work restriction is not an acceptable List C document. Ask for a different one.
- If you use E-Verify, a List B document presented with a List C document must have a photograph.
Give the employee the full list of acceptable documents that comes with the form, and let them choose.
Section 2, field by field
- Document title. Write it as it appears on the Lists of Acceptable Documents.
- Issuing authority. For example, the state that issued a driver’s license or the U.S. Department of State for a passport.
- Document number, if it has one.
- Expiration date, if it has one. Enter it even if the document is valid for years.
- Leave the other columns blank. If you fill in List A, List B and C stay empty, and the other way round.
- Additional Information box. Use it for receipts, extensions and, if you are an E-Verify employer using remote examination, the alternative-procedure checkbox.
- First day of employment. The date the employee started, or will start, work for wages.
- Your certification. Name, title, signature and the date you examined the documents.
- Business name and address. A physical address. USCIS says a P.O. box is not allowed. With several sites, use the address most appropriate to where the form is completed.
Then hand the documents back.
The “reasonably appears genuine” test
You are not a forensic examiner. USCIS asks whether a document reasonably appears to be genuine and to relate to the person presenting it. If it does, you must accept it. If it does not, let the employee present other documents from the lists. Rejecting documents that pass that test, or demanding more than the form requires, risks a discrimination claim, which is a separate problem from an incomplete form.
Receipts: valid, but only for a while
An employee can sometimes show a receipt in place of a document. The USCIS receipts page lists three main types:
| Receipt | Valid for | What must follow |
|---|---|---|
| Application to replace a lost, stolen or damaged document | 90 days from the hire date | The replacement document, or other acceptable documents |
| I-94 arrival record with temporary I-551 stamp and photo | Until the stamp expires, or 1 year from issue if no date | Permanent resident card |
| I-94 with refugee admission stamp or “RE” code | 90 days from the hire date | An employment authorization document, or a List B document plus an unrestricted Social Security card |
Two traps. Receipts cannot be used at all if the job will last less than 3 days. And you need a diary system: put a reminder on day 80 for any 90-day receipt, so the follow-up happens before it lapses rather than after.
Copies, authorized representatives and remote hires
Copies. USCIS says you may copy the documents you review, and that copies should be made consistently for all new hires, because a selective practice can look like discrimination. E-Verify employers must keep copies of certain documents, such as a U.S. passport or permanent resident card, and anyone using remote examination must keep copies of everything presented that way. Store copies with the I-9, so you can produce them together in an inspection. If you scan rather than photocopy, a phone scanner app is fine; this short guide on scanning a document with your phone covers getting a legible image. You still complete Section 2 from the originals.
Authorized representatives. You can designate anyone to complete Section 2 on your behalf, for example when a remote hire lives far from an office. You remain liable for their mistakes. The employee cannot be their own representative, and a notary acting as your representative should not add a notary seal.
Remote examination. Only employers enrolled in E-Verify in good standing may examine documents over live video under the DHS alternative procedure. Everyone else must examine the documents physically, in person or through an authorized representative.
The errors that show up most often
- Telling the employee which documents to bring.
- Finishing Section 2 after the third business day.
- Filling in List A and Lists B and C at once.
- Leaving out expiration dates or the first day of employment.
- A P.O. box as the business address.
- Accepting a restricted Social Security card as List C.
- Correction fluid or overwriting instead of a proper correction.
To correct Section 2, USCIS says to draw a line through the wrong entry, write the correct information, and initial and date the change. Do not conceal changes, and add a note to the file explaining any change or redo.
How long to keep the form
Keep each I-9 for 3 years after the hire date or 1 year after employment ends, whichever is later. Never mail it to USCIS or ICE; you store it and produce it on request. If you bring someone back after a gap, our guide to when a rehire needs a new Form I-9 covers Supplement B and the three-year window.
The I-9 is one item on the first-week list; our onboarding guide fits it into the rest.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I complete Section 2 before the employee’s first day?
Yes, once the offer has been accepted. Enter the expected first day of employment. If the start date then changes, cross out the expected date, write the actual one, and initial and date the correction. What you cannot do is ask for documents before the offer is made, because that turns verification into a screening step.
Who counts as a business day for the deadline?
USCIS’s handbook gives the Monday-to-Thursday example but does not publish its own definition of business day. Treat it as your normal operating days and do not rely on a holiday or weekend to stretch the window. If the employee starts on a Friday, plan to finish by the following Wednesday at the latest.
What if the employee cannot produce any acceptable document within three days?
Unless they present a valid receipt, the USCIS handbook says you may terminate an employee who fails to present acceptable documentation within three business days. Apply the same rule to everyone. Before taking that step, make sure you have given them the full list of acceptable documents, not just the two or three you are used to seeing.
Do I need a new I-9 when an employee changes their name?
Not normally. The USCIS handbook says that outside a rehire or reverification, you are not required to update the form, but it recommends entering the new legal name in the New Name fields of Supplement B and signing and dating that block as soon as you learn of the change. You may ask for legal proof, such as a court order, and keep a copy with the I-9.
Let the employee choose, record exactly what you saw, sign inside three business days, and file the form away from the personnel record. That covers nearly every finding an inspector would make.