For most private employers in the US, E-Verify is optional under federal law. It becomes required in two situations: you hold a federal contract that contains the FAR E-Verify clause, or your state has made it mandatory for some or all employers. Arizona, for example, requires every employer to use it, and Florida requires it of private employers with 25 or more employees.
Everyone, with or without E-Verify, must still complete Form I-9 for each new hire. The sections below cover the federal contractor rule and its deadlines, how to check your state, what you sign up to when you enrol voluntarily, and the rules that most often get participating employers into trouble.
Three questions that settle it
- Do you have a federal contract or subcontract with the FAR E-Verify clause? If yes, you must use it for covered employees.
- Does your state require it for an employer of your size or type? If yes, you must use it for new hires in that state.
- Neither? Then it is your choice. Enrolling is free, but it comes with obligations covered below.
Federal contractors: the FAR clause
E-Verify’s own federal contractor rule page sets out who is covered. A prime contract is covered when it includes the FAR E-Verify clause, runs for 120 days or more, is worth more than $150,000, and involves some work in the United States. Subcontracts are covered when they are worth more than $3,500 for services or construction with US work.
Some contracts are exempt, such as those for commercially available off-the-shelf items. If you see the clause in a contract, check E-Verify’s exemptions page before assuming it does not apply.
Deadlines once you are covered
| Step | Deadline |
|---|---|
| Enrol in E-Verify (if not already enrolled) | Within 30 calendar days of contract award |
| Start verifying all new hires | Within 90 calendar days of enrolment |
| Verify existing employees assigned to the contract | Within 90 days of enrolment or 30 days of assignment, whichever is later |
| Optional: verify the entire existing workforce | Within 180 days of enrolment or of notifying E-Verify |
Already enrolled? Do not re-enrol. Update your company profile to show federal contractor status within 30 days of the award, then follow the same timeframes for employees on the contract.
State mandates: check your own state
State rules are where most small employers get caught. E-Verify’s history page records that, as of September 2024, 21 states had contracting or business-licensing laws making E-Verify enrolment a condition for some or all employers: Alabama, Arizona, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Louisiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Nebraska, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia and West Virginia.
That list mixes very different rules. In several of those states the requirement reaches only public employers or businesses with state contracts. Others reach private employers. Two examples from the statutes themselves:
- Arizona: A.R.S. 23-214 requires every employer to verify each new employee through E-Verify and keep a record of the verification for the length of employment or at least three years, whichever is longer.
- Florida: section 448.095 of the 2026 Florida Statutes requires private employers with 25 or more employees to use E-Verify for new hires, and to certify compliance on the first unemployment tax return each calendar year.
For any other state on the list, read the current statute or the state labor department’s guidance, because thresholds and dates change. If you have remote employees, the rule that applies is generally the one for the state where they work.
What you sign up for when you enrol
Enrolment is online and free. You add your company details and hiring sites, name a program administrator and a signatory, and the signatory accepts the E-Verify memorandum of understanding (MOU). From then on, you are bound by its terms and the user manual, whether you joined voluntarily or not.
E-Verify now signs users in through Login.gov, which uses a second sign-in step. If whoever runs your HR has not set one up before, this plain guide to setting up two-factor authentication explains the options, such as an authenticator app.
Rules that trip up participating employers
Must do
- Display the E-Verify participation notice and the Justice Department’s Right to Work poster, in English and Spanish, and include them with application materials.
- Create the case no later than the third business day after the employee starts work for pay.
- Give the employee the Further Action Notice if the case returns a mismatch.
- Let the employee keep working while a mismatch is resolved.
Must not do
- Run a case before the person has accepted the offer and completed Form I-9. No pre-screening of applicants.
- Use E-Verify on existing employees, except where the federal contractor rule allows it.
- Fire, suspend, delay training or withhold pay because someone is contesting a mismatch.
- Tell employees which I-9 documents to present.
- Use it to reverify an employee whose work permit has expired. That is done on Form I-9 Supplement B.
All of this rests on a properly completed I-9. Our walkthrough of completing Form I-9 Section 2 covers the employer’s part, and E-Verify employers also gain access to the remote document option described in our guide to remote I-9 verification.
Should you enrol if you do not have to?
Reasons employers enrol voluntarily:
- It is free and returns many results in seconds.
- It gives you access to the DHS alternative procedure for examining I-9 documents remotely.
- State law can reward it. Florida’s statute, for instance, refers to a rebuttable presumption that employers can rely on when they use E-Verify.
Reasons to hold off:
- You must use it for every new hire at enrolled sites, consistently.
- Posters, case deadlines and mismatch procedures add administrative steps.
- Mishandling a mismatch can create discrimination exposure that a paper-only I-9 process does not.
A reasonable rule: if you hire regularly, have remote staff, or expect federal or state contracts, enrol and build the process carefully. If you hire twice a year in a state with no mandate, a well-run I-9 process may be enough.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does E-Verify replace Form I-9?
No. You still complete and keep a Form I-9 for every new hire. E-Verify takes the information from the completed I-9 and checks it against Department of Homeland Security and Social Security Administration records. If you stop using E-Verify, the I-9 obligation remains exactly the same.
Can I run E-Verify on a job applicant?
No. A case can only be created after the person has accepted a job offer and completed Form I-9. Using E-Verify to screen applicants before an offer breaks the program rules and can expose you to discrimination claims. Make the offer first, complete the I-9, then create the case.
What happens if an employee gets a mismatch?
Give the employee the Further Action Notice and let them decide whether to resolve it. If they do, provide the referral date confirmation and let them keep working with no change in pay, training or schedule while the case is pending. Only a final nonconfirmation allows you to act on the result.
Does the state rule follow my headquarters or my employees?
Generally the employees. State E-Verify laws usually apply to hiring in that state, so a company based in a no-mandate state that hires a remote employee in Arizona must follow Arizona’s rule for that hire. Check the wording of each statute, because some tie the duty to state contracts or business licences instead.
Do I need to verify existing employees when I enrol?
No, and in most cases you are not allowed to. Voluntary participants verify new hires only. Federal contractors are the exception: they must verify existing employees assigned to a covered contract and may choose to verify their whole workforce within the set timeframes.
Check your contracts for the FAR clause, read your state’s statute, and if you do enrol, verify every new hire within three business days and never before the I-9 is done.