Remote I-9 Verification: Using the DHS Alternative Procedure

You can verify a remote employee’s Form I-9 documents over live video only if your business is enrolled in E-Verify and in good standing. That is the DHS “alternative procedure”. Every other employer must still have the documents examined physically, which for a remote hire means appointing an authorized representative near the employee to look at them in person.

Both routes are legal and both work. The choice comes down to whether you already use E-Verify, or are willing to join it, and how many remote hires you make. Below are the exact steps for each, the consistency rule that trips people up, and what to store afterwards.

Route A: the DHS alternative procedure (E-Verify employers)

Who qualifies

USCIS’s page on remote examination of documents sets the test. You must participate in E-Verify in good standing, which means you:

  • are enrolled in E-Verify for every hiring site that uses the alternative procedure,
  • use E-Verify to confirm the employment eligibility of new hires in the United States, and
  • comply with all the other E-Verify program requirements.

New E-Verify enrollees and users must also complete the E-Verify tutorial, which includes fraudulent document awareness training. Existing users can retake it at any time, which is worth doing before you start remote examinations.

The three steps

  1. Get copies first. The employee sends you copies of the documents they have chosen from the Lists of Acceptable Documents, front and back if two-sided. Examine them to check they reasonably appear genuine and relate to the employee.
  2. Hold a live video call. The employee presents the same documents on camera. A recorded video or a still photo is not enough; it has to be a live interaction.
  3. Keep clear copies. Retain legible copies of every document examined this way, front and back, for as long as you keep the I-9.

Then complete Section 2 as normal, by the third business day after the employee starts, and check the box in the Additional Information field showing you used an alternative procedure. That box exists on the 08/01/2023 and 01/20/2025 editions of the form. If you are somehow still using the 10/21/2019 edition, USCIS says to write “Alternative Procedure” in that field instead.

Running the call well

A shaky phone camera in a dark room makes it hard to judge whether a card reasonably appears genuine. Before the call, tell the employee to:

  • sit somewhere well lit, facing a window or lamp,
  • have all the documents within reach, out of any plastic sleeves,
  • be ready to tilt each card toward the camera and show the back.

If the connection drops repeatedly, reschedule rather than accept a frozen frame. This plain guide to fixing common video call problems is a handy link to send a new hire before the call.

The consistency rule: who you offer it to

This is where the alternative procedure can create legal risk. USCIS says that if you offer it to new employees at an E-Verify hiring site, you must do so consistently for all employees at that site. You may limit it to remote hires, keeping physical examination for onsite and hybrid staff, as long as that choice is not discriminatory and does not treat employees differently based on citizenship, immigration status or national origin.

In practice, write down a one-line policy per site before the first remote hire, for example: “At this site, all fully remote employees are offered remote examination; all onsite and hybrid employees are examined in person.” Then follow it without exceptions. Deciding case by case who “can” use video is exactly what the rule is meant to stop.

Route B: an authorized representative (everyone else)

If you do not use E-Verify, the documents must be examined in the employee’s physical presence. You do not have to fly someone out. USCIS allows you to designate an authorized representative to complete Section 2 on your behalf.

  • Who it can be: anyone you designate. Employers often use a trusted colleague in the same city, an accountant or another professional they already work with.
  • Who it cannot be: the employee themselves.
  • Notaries: a notary can act as your representative, but in that role they are not acting as a notary and should not add a seal.
  • Liability: you remain responsible for any mistakes your representative makes.

Send the representative the blank form, the employee’s completed Section 1, the Lists of Acceptable Documents, and a short instruction sheet: examine the original documents in person, complete Section 2 with title, issuing authority, number and expiry for each, enter your business’s physical address, sign, and return the form within the three-business-day window. Our Section 2 walkthrough makes a good instruction sheet on its own.

Route A or B? A quick comparison

Factor Alternative procedure Authorized representative
Requires E-Verify Yes, in good standing No
Who examines documents You, by live video Your designee, in person
Copies Must keep Optional (but apply your policy consistently)
Best for Regular remote hiring across many locations Occasional remote hires

Storage: what an inspector will ask for

The usual I-9 retention clock applies (three years from hire, or one year past the last day of work if that ends later), and you keep the document copies alongside it. If a federal inspector reviews your forms, USCIS says you must provide the copies of the identity and work authorization documents the employee presented through the alternative procedure. Store them with the I-9s, not in a shared drive folder that someone may tidy away. USCIS’s handbook section on retaining document copies covers the details.

Rehires and reverification

The alternative procedure also works for rehires and for reverifying an employee whose work authorization is expiring. On the current editions, check the box in Supplement B. For a reverification, do not create a new E-Verify case. If you are bringing someone back after a gap, our guide to when a rehire needs a new I-9 explains whether Supplement B is enough.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use remote examination for an employee who works in the office?

Yes, if you are an E-Verify employer in good standing and you offer it consistently to everyone at that hiring site. What you cannot do is offer it to some onsite employees and not others on a basis connected to citizenship, immigration status or national origin. If you want to limit it to remote staff only, that is allowed, provided the split is applied without exceptions.

Is a FaceTime or Zoom call acceptable?

USCIS requires a live video interaction with the employee and does not name a particular app. Any reliable platform that lets you see the person and the documents clearly in real time should meet the requirement. Avoid anything that sends recorded clips instead of a live feed, and do not record the call unless you have a reason and have told the employee.

What if a document looks wrong on video?

Treat it the way you would in person: if a document does not reasonably appear genuine or relate to the employee, let them present other acceptable documents from the lists. Do not demand a particular replacement document. If video quality is the issue rather than the document, rearrange the call, or switch to an in-person examination through an authorized representative.

We are not in E-Verify. Should we enroll just for this?

Possibly, if you hire remotely often. Enrollment brings its own obligations: you must use E-Verify for every new hire at the enrolled site and follow all program rules, not just the remote-examination ones. For one or two remote hires a year, an authorized representative is usually simpler.

Check your E-Verify status, write the one-line consistency policy, and then pick the route. Either one gets a remote hire verified inside three business days.