Contingency recruiters are paid only if you hire someone they introduced. Retained search firms are paid to run the search itself, usually in instalments that start before any candidate appears, and they work for you exclusively. Everything else follows from that difference: how hard the recruiter works your role, how many firms you can use at once, and what level of job each model suits.
As a rough guide, contingency fits roles where many qualified people exist and speed matters, and retained fits senior, confidential or hard-to-fill roles where you need a methodical search. This article compares the two side by side, covers the hybrid “engaged” model, and lists the contract terms and questions that matter before you sign either.
Side-by-side comparison
| Point | Contingency | Retained |
|---|---|---|
| When you pay | Only when a referred candidate starts | In stages, beginning when the search starts |
| Exclusivity | Usually none; you can use several firms | Exclusive to one firm |
| Typical roles | Individual contributors, early and mid-level | Executives, senior specialists, confidential replacements |
| Recruiter’s incentive | Fill fast, compete with other firms | Complete a thorough search and report on it |
| What you get | CVs of available candidates | Market mapping, outreach, assessment, progress reports |
| If you hire elsewhere | You usually owe nothing | You have usually paid much of the fee already |
How contingency recruiting works for you
A contingency recruiter takes your job order, searches their network and databases, and sends you candidates. If you hire one, you pay a placement fee, typically calculated as a percentage of the hire’s first-year base salary. If you do not, you pay nothing.
The appeal is obvious: no risk until someone starts. The trade-off is less obvious. A contingency recruiter working the same role as two other firms is paid only if they win the race, so their rational move is to send the most available candidates quickly and spend time on whichever client is most likely to hire. Your hard-to-fill role may get less attention than you think.
Getting the best from contingency firms
- Use one or two firms, not five. Recruiters work harder on roles they have a real chance of filling.
- Give fast feedback on every CV. Silence pushes your role down their list.
- Agree candidate ownership rules in writing so two firms cannot both claim the same person.
- Check the replacement terms. Our guide to what a fair recruiter replacement guarantee covers explains which conditions matter.
How retained search works for you
A retained firm is engaged to conduct a defined search. The fee is commonly split into stages, such as on signing, at the presentation of a shortlist and on the hire, and the firm commits to a process: defining the role with you, mapping the market, approaching people who are not looking, assessing them, and reporting progress.
You are paying for that process and the firm’s time, not only the outcome. If you cancel the search or fill the role internally, the instalments already paid are usually not refundable. That is the risk you take in exchange for a dedicated team and a disciplined search.
Retained search is closely associated with executive search. The Association of Executive Search and Leadership Consultants, a trade body for the sector, publishes professional standards and a client bill of rights that set out what members commit to, including confidentiality and objective assessment. Membership is voluntary, so treat it as one signal, not a guarantee.
When retained is worth the commitment
- The role is senior and a mis-hire would be expensive.
- The search must stay confidential, for example when replacing someone still in post.
- The best candidates are employed and not reading job ads.
- You need a documented, defensible process for a board or investors.
The middle option: engaged or container searches
Some firms offer a hybrid, often called an engaged or container search. You pay a smaller upfront fee that secures the firm’s priority attention and exclusivity, and the balance on hire. It suits roles that are too difficult for a casual contingency approach but not senior enough to justify a full retained search. Ask exactly what the upfront payment buys, how it is credited against the final fee, and what happens if you stop.
Contract terms to read before signing either
- Fee base. Is the percentage applied to base salary only, or to base plus target bonus, signing bonus and other cash? The difference can be large.
- Payment schedule. For retained work, when each instalment is due and whether any is refundable.
- Candidate ownership period. How long a fee is owed if you hire someone the firm introduced, even for a different role.
- Off-limits rules. Whether the firm can recruit from your company after the search, and for how long.
- Expenses. Advertising, travel and assessment costs, and whether they are capped.
- Guarantee. Length, remedy and exclusions if the hire leaves early.
For a broader look at how agency fees are structured across temp, temp-to-hire and permanent placements, see our explainer on staffing agency fees.
A legal point that applies to both models
Whoever you use, the hiring decision is still yours, and so is the legal responsibility for how candidates are selected. The EEOC’s guidance on staffing firms and clients says a firm is liable if it honours a client’s discriminatory request, and the client’s requirement is no defence. A brief that asks for “a young, energetic team player” or someone “from a similar background” invites exactly that problem. Write the brief around skills, results and experience.
Questions to ask any recruiter before you choose
- How many searches like this have you completed in the last year, and can I speak to one of those clients?
- How will you find people who are not actively looking?
- Who will actually work on my search, and how much of their time does it get?
- How do you assess candidates before I see them?
- What reports will I receive, and how often?
- What happens if the search stalls after 60 days?
Recruiting is a profession with its own career data. If you want to understand who you are hiring to do this work, the occupation profile for human resources specialists, the category that includes recruiters, covers typical duties and pay.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is retained search always more expensive?
Not necessarily in percentage terms, but you pay part of it regardless of outcome. A contingency fee is only paid on success, so if the search fails it costs nothing. A retained search that fails still costs the instalments paid. Compare the total expected cost against the value of filling the role well and on time.
Can I use a contingency recruiter and post the job myself?
Usually yes. Contingency agreements are rarely exclusive, so you can advertise and hire directly. Agree in writing which candidates the recruiter has introduced, so there is no dispute over a fee if one of your own applicants also appears in their shortlist.
How long does a retained search usually take?
It depends on the role, the market and how quickly you can interview. Ask the firm for a timeline with milestones, such as when you will see the market map, the longlist and the shortlist, and build those dates into the contract so you can measure progress.
Should I switch from contingency to retained if a role is not filling?
Consider it if the role has stayed open for months despite several firms working it. First check the basics: pay against the market, a realistic job description and your own interview speed. If those are sound, a retained or engaged search can bring the focus a crowded contingency race does not.
Pay on success for roles the market can fill quickly; pay for a process when the role is senior, confidential or rare. Then read the fee base and the guarantee before you sign anything.